Goodreads Review – “Guay builds a world with a creepy Victorian vibe”

Another review of S&S, this time from ‘Jennifer’ on Goodreads:

This is what the editors are calling “paranormal anthology” – not necessarily ghost stories, though. Think more along the lines of Neil Gaiman or Stephen King. I find that most short story collections are something of a mixed bag – even single author collections – and this anthology is no exception. The quality of the writing is a bit uneven in that some authors clearly have more experience/talent/better editors. However, even where the writing isn’t necessarily as polished, the stories themselves are imaginative and entertaining. The good ones are very, very good, and the bad ones easily skipped. For this reviewer, only two stories were real clunkers (sadly, the first story in the collection is one of these so if you, like me, find it hard to get through please keep going) and the rest highly enjoyable. Overall, I’d say the collection is well worth a read.

My favorites, all by authors I’d happily read more from:

“China Doll” by Ginger C. Mann – am I allowed to call a tale that includes tragic accidents and death charming? What about one with a kindly mysterious old man who fixes toys with magic, and helps a young girl to realize her own talents in that area? I think that’s ok, right? So a charming little story, drew me right in.

“Child of the Underworld” by Marian Rosarum – If Nathaniel Hawthorne, Neil Gaiman and Edgar Allan Poe sat down to write a short story, this is the sort of thing they would come up with. Deliciously creepy and otherworldly and sad.

“Tombstone” by Scott E. Tarbet – hilarious ghost story about a cranky old farmer/murder victim who haunts his own property. Laugh-out-loud funny, especially if you happen to know any old farmers.

“The Death of Dr. Marcus Wells” by J. Aurel Guay – this is the one story in the collection that I wish had been expanded into a novella or even a full-length novel. Guay builds a world with a creepy Victorian vibe – think Drood-era Dickens – and then populates it with creepy viral monsters. The story is great fun, but there are enough unanswered questions that this reader, at least, hopes Guay will revisit this world and its stories in the future.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s